The Final Extinction of Trilobites
To all good things, there comes an end...
This page last revised 27 March 2006 by S.M Gon III


phillipsia
Although the Trilobita went entirely extinct at the end of the Permian (251 million years ago [mya]), when >90% of all species on the planet were extinguished, the pattern of decline for trilobites had been significant since the end of the Ordovocian. By the end of the Devonian (359 mya), the last of the Phacopidae went extinct, ending the order Phacopida. All of the orders of trilobites had gone extinct, except for one: the Proetida. This order persisted into the Carboniferous (with two superfamilies represented: Aulacopleuroidea and Proetoidea. There was even a major adaptive radiation among the family Phillipsiidae (especially various subfamilies such as Phillipsiinae and Ditomopyginae) in the early Carboniferous, as changes in the world's continents created expanding habitat opportunities. But the number of taxa fell dramatically after the Mid-Carboniferous, and by the start of the Permian (299 mya), only the families Brachymetopidae, Phillipsiidae, and Proetidae remained. The table below lists all of the trilobite genera that existed in the Permian, and indicates when these genera became extinct.  

Trilobite Genera Extinctions in the Permian
Superfamily
Family
Subfamily
Genus
Extinction
Aulacopleuroidea
Brachymetopidae
Brachymetopinae
Cheiropyge
End Permian



Brachymetopus
Early Permian
Proetoidea
Proetidae*
Proetinae
Neogriffithides
Middle Permian



Anujaspis
Early Permian

Phillipsiidae*
Archegoninae
Hildaphillipsia
Middle Permian


Bollandiinae
Kathwaia
End Permian



Neoproetus
Middle Permian


Cummingellinae
Bedicella
Early Permian



Cummingella
Early Permian



Paraphillipsia
End Permian


Ditomopyginae
Acanthophillipsia
Middle Permian



Acropyge
End Permian



Ameura
Early Permian



Ampulliglabella
Middle Permian



Anisopyge
Middle Permian



Delaria
Middle Permian



Ditomopyge
Late Permian



Hentigia
Early Permian



Iranaspidion
Late Permian



Jimbokranion
Middle Permian



Microphillipsia
Middle Permian



Novoameura
Early Permian



Permoproetus
Middle Permian



Pseudophillipsia
End Permian



Timoraspis
Middle Permian



Triproetus
Middle Permian


Weaniinae
Doublatia
Early Permian



Endops
Middle Permian



Nipponaspis
Middle Permian



Weania
Early Permian
*In the list of generic names of trilobites in Jell and Adrain 2003, the family Phillipsiidae is reduced in rank to a subfamily within the Proetidae.

The Last Trilobites
What were the last trilobite species alive? 

Owens (2003) reviewed the last trilobites to go extinct during the Permian, and revealed that five genera of trilobites persisted until the great extinction crisis at the end of the Permian. This event was perhaps the largest extinction event in Earth's history, wherein >90% of all species were extinguished. However, the fossil record reveals that for trilobites, there were two crises during the Permian, one during the Middle Permian (266 million years ago, in the Late Guadalupian Epoch), in which over half of the trilobite genera extant at the time were lost (see the numerous "Middle Permian" extinctions in the table above). Of those that remained, only five persisted to the end Permian event: Cheiropyge (an aulacopleuroid in the family Brachymetopidae), Kathwaia (a proetoid in the family Phillipsiidae, subfamily Bollandiinae), Paraphillipsia (Phillipsiidae, Cummingellinae), Acropyge (Phillipsiidae, Ditomopyginae), and Pseudophillipsia (also Ditomopyginae). Specimens of these genera are shown at right: These are the last genera of the trilobites, and are found in various localities today including Pakistan, China, Russia, Hungary, and Japan. 

Reconstructions of three of these Permian trilobite species are presented at bottom right:  Leftmost: Cheiropyge koizumii (Japan, Brachymetopidae); Middle: Pseudophillipsia sumatrensis (Malaysia, Proetidae); Far right: Paraphillipsia karpinskyii (Ukraine, Proetidae)
permian trilobites
Three Permian trilobites

Last Word:
As Owens (2003) stated: "But for the extreme stresses that the entire marine biota suffered towards the end of the Permian, trilobites would probably have survived for much longer. Their numbers and diversity both severely decreased during the late Guadalupe Epoch, thereby strongly reducing their chances of surviving the end Permian extinction that followed." Thus, it is not necessary to look for a reason entirely intrinsic to trilobites for their extinction. Theirs was a design that was viable for 291 million years – a feat exceeded by only a few other animal groups.

Literature citation:

Owens, R.M. 2003. The stratigraphical distribution and extinctions of Permian trilobites. Special Papers in Palaeontology 70:377-97.



Related links:
Trilobites in geological time - over what period of time did trilobites exist?
Trilobite evolutionary trends -
after their origin, trilobites diversified in many directions.
Trilobite ontogeny - how did trilobites develop, and what does this tell us about their evolution and relationships?
Trilobite relationships - where do trilobites fall among early arthropods?
Trilobite origins - what do we know about the ancestors of trilobites?
Trilobite trace fossils - what kinds of traces did trilobites leave?
stroll with me among the topics below...
Walking Trilobite animation ©2000 by S. M. Gon III